Thursday, February 3, 2011

Greed is Not Good

Just a quick reminder to everybody. Greed is not good.

I say this because lately me and another engineering friend of mine were discussing economic matter and, even though I know he has taken micro- and macro-economics, he told me that "Greed is good". That baffled me. That is not something you should expect of hearing out of a college student who has studied economics.

The general misconception about this topic is that greed makes markets efficient and deadweight loss disappear. This would also mean no government intervention in order for the 'greed' to work flawlessly.

The misconception is about the word 'greed' which is used as 'self-interest' while it really has a definition that is not so positive:

Greed - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia: "Greed is an excessive desire to possess wealth or goods with the intention to keep it for one's self. Greed - like lust and gluttony - is a sin of excess. Greed is inappropriate expectation. However, greed is applied to a very excessive or rapacious desire and pursuit of wealth, status, and power.
As a secular psychological concept, greed is an inordinate desire to acquire or possess more than one needs or deserves, especially with respect to material wealth."

'Greed' is the blind accumulation of material goods, while 'self-interest' is the innate desire of pursuing what is good for you. To this I would add that greed is usually meant as "the ends justify the means" approach. In other words to say that 'greed is good' is to say that your own personal and material wealth is a good thing and if in the process of doing it you hurt somebody, that's fine anyway because greed is good.
'Self interest' on the other hand has a more relaxed meaning which is not limited to material good and not even personal benefit. It is more similar to 'the pursuit of happiness' rather than greed, and it certainly does not imply hurting somebody else.

The second issue with this mentality is that economists have proven to actually not work. The premise of Adam Smith 'invisible hand' is the context of a "perfectly competitive market". Such market would have a numerous number of small firms, all of which produce exact products, they all have free entry and exit costs, they are all 'price takers', they have and they all have the same information about the market and the product they are selling. In such market no government intervention is needed because their self interest will make each other work efficiently and the market wont generate inefficiencies.

The problem is that there is no such market in real life. Some get close enough that we can model it that way and thus argue for reducing government intervention, but the majority of the markets are not of this kind. Those that produce the most inefficiencies are not 'perfectly competitive markets'.

Summarizing:
  • It is known that greed is good in some cases, but these are not the most common by a long shot.
  • Economists do actually study these situations and when they describe the engine of markets they talk about 'self-interest' or 'maximizing satisfaction' and none of them use the word greed.
  • I take issue with the word greed being used to describe what it is not greed, especially because other people who might hear 'greed is good' distractingly don't associate the meaning that the speaker intended. I would say that unconsciously even the speaker would convince himself that greed is good and act greedy as a consequence.
  • Spreading this false sense that 'greed is good' in our society will change us culturally, making us more willing to accept greedy behavior from other people.

No comments:

Post a Comment